Using Multimodal AI to Ensure Accountability in High-Stakes Litigation
The Challenge
In legal disputes, the truth isn't always just in the words spoken; it's in how they are delivered. A plaintiff in a high-value civil case faced a critical challenge: proving systemic bias from an authority figure. Without objective proof, subjective claims of interrupted speech and anger could be dismissed. They needed a way to use solid data to validate human behavior and build an undeniable case that met the high standards of judicial evidence.
Case Background
This specific case involved the theft of valuable digital property. The plaintiff noticed a clear pattern: the judge’s decisions consistently went against clear evidence and standard legal rules, unfairly benefiting the other side. Making this problem worse, the court alone controlled the official audio recordings. This meant proof of the judge’s bias—like constantly talking over the plaintiff, using a hostile tone, or making questionable comments—could easily be edited or disappear. The goal was to secure this evidence independently and analyze it in a way that would meet the strict Daubert standards for scientific evidence, ensuring it would be admissible in court.
The Search for a Solution
The plaintiff knew that a simple analysis wouldn't be enough. They needed a solution that could combine an understanding of vocal tone, speech content, and facial expressions all at once. After evaluating other options, they found that many platforms were missing key features or weren't built on a scientific foundation strong enough for the courtroom.
Why Imentiv AI?
Imentiv AI was chosen because it offered what other platforms didn't:
- Complete Analysis: Imentiv AI combines the analysis of facial expressions, vocal tone, and words to provide a full picture of what is being communicated.
- Scientific Trust: The platform is built on validated research, which is crucial for evidence to be accepted in court.
- Practical Flexibility: Even with imperfect video sources, the platform can be used to gather clear and reliable emotion data.
- User-Friendliness: Imentiv offers an intuitive, easy-to-navigate interface that simplifies complex multimodal analysis for professionals without technical expertise.
The Imentiv AI Solution
Imentiv AI provided a complete solution.
- Accurate Data: The team used Imentiv's service to correct the hearing transcript manually, ensuring the AI's analysis was based on 100% accurate text.
- Precise Insights: The AI pinpointed critical moments: interruptions, changes in vocal tone (indicating anger), and corresponding facial expressions that revealed deeper emotions.
- Expert Validation: Imentiv's in-house psychology expert provided a formal report, turning data into expert-backed findings that could be used to support the case.
The Result
The objective data from Imentiv AI created a powerful and undeniable narrative. This evidence was successfully presented to the court, significantly advancing the case. This success presents a new approach in the legal landscape, demonstrating that AI-driven analysis is now a practical and powerful tool for the legal world.
Imentiv’s ability to go beyond subjective claims and provide verifiable, data-backed evidence is ushering in a new era of accountability in the courtroom.
It gives legal professionals the power to:
- Support claims of bias or misconduct with hard data
- Analyze depositions and testimony to assess credibility
- Build stronger, evidence-based cases that stand up to intense scrutiny
Request a demo with our team today!